Recurrent: Ministry of Finance
Resolution appealed: R CTBG 0985/2026
In exercise of the right of access to public information, the MINISTRY OF FINANCE was requested a copy of the official communications and correspondence exchanged between the General Directorate of Taxes and the Ministry of Finance of Andorra between September 2018 and September 2019, relating exclusively to the interpretation of the clause of substantial participation provided for in article 13.5 of the Agreement between Spain and Andorra to avoid double taxation.
The Ministry issued a resolution in which it agreed to deny access on the grounds that the information exchanged between the competent authorities has the character of secrecy, subject to a specific regime of confidentiality derived from the Spanish-Andorran Convention, adding the concurrence of the limits provided in article 14.1. c) and k) LTAIBG, and citing as precedent the resolution of this Council R/0073/2016, of 9 May.
The Council considers the claim, considering that the specific communications requested on the interpretation of Article 13.5 of the Double Taxation Convention are not covered by the duty of secrecy provided for in Article 24 of the Convention. It also points out that this provision does not constitute a special regime of access to information that displaces the application of the LTAIBG, but rather a regulation of the exchange of relevant tax information between States, imposing confidentiality only with respect to the tax data and information transmitted for the exercise of their administrative powers.
The Council distinguishes between the tax information exchanged, which is confidential, and the interpretative criteria on the Convention, which are not, concluding that extending this confidentiality to communications on how to interpret a rule of the Convention is contrary to the principles of publicity, legal certainty and the interdiction of arbitrariness. Consequently, it understands that this is information of legal relevance, the publication of which is mandatory under Article 7(a) LTAIBG.