The contentious appeal is presented by the Spanish Radio Television Corporation (CRTVE) against the resolution of the Council of Transparency and Good Government that estimates the right of the applicant to know the cost of the musical specials broadcast on Christmas Eve, the broadcast of the bells and the gala of Feliz 2017, all of them broadcast in 1. The Transparency Council excluded from access the individualized salaries of the presenters and the expenses in salaries of their workers on the understanding that there could be a violation of their right to the protection of personal data.