Recurrent: Repsol Soluciones Energético, S.A.
Resolution appealed: R CTBG 1081/2026
In exercise of the right of access to public information, the appellant requested the National Commission on Markets and Competition (CNMC) to have access to documents forming part of file S/0006/25, excluding those elements which, in the Administration ' s opinion, were confidential.
The CNMC issued a resolution in which it agreed to deny access, indicating that the information requested is of a reserved nature and that no file has been initiated. Later, at the allegation stage, it refers to the damage caused by the delivery of information for the prevention, investigation and punishment of illicit acts, as well as for the functions of surveillance, inspection and control of the markets and productive sectors that it has entrusted.
Due to the extraordinary increase in the number of complaints filed with the CTBG, the CTBG did not resolve in due time the complaint filed by the now appellant, who filed an administrative appeal against the alleged dismissal of this Council. However, in accordance with the provisions of Article 21.1 LPAC, the Council issued a resolution estimating the claim, and recalls the existence of a consolidated jurisprudence of the Supreme Court, which recognizes the right of affected persons to have access to previous or reserved proceedings even when they are concluded without sanction (Judgment of September 25, 2023, ECLI:ES:TS:2023:3748). It also points out that article 45 of 5/2007, of 3 July, on Competition Protection (LDC), refers alternately to the LPACAP, whose article 53 recognizes the right of access to those affected by administrative actions. On the other hand, it stresses that the application of the limits provided for in Article 14.1(e) and (g) LTAIBG, relating to the prevention and investigation of unlawful acts and to the monitoring and inspection functions, requires specific justification and weighting, by means of the corresponding damage tests and public interest tests, which it considers have not been duly carried out. Finally, it adds that the existence of personal data or confidential information belonging to other economic operators does not justify a total refusal of the request, but that, in accordance with the provisions of Article 15.4 LTAIBG, it is appropriate to provide documentation upon dissociation of personal data and deletion of confidential content of third parties.